Philadelphia Eagles: Free Safety- # 20 Brian Dawkins 11yrs pro (age 33)

7 Prowbowls (1999, 2001, 2002, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007)

Baltimore Ravens: Free Safety- # 20 Ed Reed 5yrs pro (age 28)

3 Probowls (2004, 2005, 2007)

NFL Record- longest interception return in history 106 yards.
NFL Record- Most interception yards in history 385 yards

Pittsburgh Steelers: Strong Safety- #43 Troy Polamalu 4yrs pro (age 25)

3 Probowls (2005, 2006, 2007)

Ed Reed is the best right now

Ed Reed for sure he plays like a beast he is just unstoppable.

Troy Polamalu

Ed Reed yeah... pretty easy question.

Brian Dawkins would be the Mvp but Ed reed has more skill cuz he is at his prime
Dawkins is a crucial part of the defense and an emotional leader..The defense wouldn't be the same without him. INfact Dawkins was a crucial part in the late run for the eagles...
polamalu ...had 1 good yr..but needs to tackle devin hester first...see probowl

Ed Reed is scary good! You cannot throw the ball near him!!

I put Polamalu second and Dawking (on your list) as third.

Reed is awesome!!!!!! It is no suprise the Ravens are constantly a top defense.

Brian Dawkins by far. Reed only works well when Ray Lewis is working well. Troy is just everywhere.

Ed Reed hands down!

None of them, John Lynch is the best, Denver Broncos, He turned around the Broncos secondary.

Ed Reed b/c he gets alot ints.

Gotta go with ED REED!

2004 Defensive Player of the Year
Ravens all time interception leader
Has blocked 4 punts and returned 3 of them for TDs!

The guy can almost single handedly cover one half, if not the entire downfield! Freakish skillz!

Ed Reed is the best he makes it almost impossible to throw it deep on the Ravens. Dawkins is an excellent hitter who tears up the middle of the field but is not amazing on deep pass coverage. Troy is a great athlete and is very smart in run and pass coverage but the other two have been around longer.

Gotta go with Ed Reed on this one... the thugs from the U can play!!!

ed reed. he's the best against the pass by far, and almost as good dawkins at knocking the **** out of you

TROY POLAMALU. Injuries skrewed up his season.

Dawkins.

ed reed . at miami the coach said he was the best player he has ever coached because ed reed basiclly coached the whole team . plus he can give big hits return punts even though he doesent anymore cover recievers RBS TEs and catches like a reciever. he has the longest pic ever in nfl history defensive player of the year. most interception yards and his strong safety dwan landry is better then polu...whatever . also who has miami coached ray lewis one of the best linebackers ever maybe the best ever. clinton portis , the edge, and micheal irvin

Troy Polamu
Even though hes got long hair

I really like what Ed Reed brings to the table. He is such a difference maker for that team. He can really take over a game single-handedly

Thank you for not including Roy Williams in this group. I can't believe he gets more love from the league than Dawkins does. Gimme a break...

ed reed

I'd say Edd Reed is the best with Darren Sharper coming in at second.After that Dawkins then Polamalu.

Polamalu- won a Superbowl with the Pittsburgh Steelers!!!

it's all about the rings!

Ed Reed

Troy Polamalu because he represents the asians well.

Ed Reed Is for now .

if your saying right now it's reed but career wise Dawkins

neither i think the best saftey in the nfl is roy williams of the dallas cowboys

Troy Polamalu He does it all no comparison to others
Blitzes very capably constantly breaking up plays fantastic
run Defender. ,Hampered this year by injuries

i beleive it is troy polamalu even though out of all those people he has been the least years been pro but if you look at his records he has made it to all the probowls exept his rookie year and he already has as much inerseptions as all the other guys and he has not as much tackles but he is going to be in football for a long time so he is going to probably have more tackles cause he always seem to be there first and with out him i dont think the pittsburgh steelers would have much of a defence yeh they would still have a decent defence but with polamalu it adds a hole different level to any defence he is on and he can even do good at returning kicks but he dosent like to do that because he said he likes to takle people not be tackled.

maybe urlacher, bruchuski, and ty law!!!!!!!!

I believe that nowadays safeties need speed. Ed Reed is the fastest out of those players, so I'd pick him just because he covers so much ground. Dawkins is a smart player and thats really what gets him to probowls (dont use probowls as a measurement because its kind of moot) and Troy has alot of upside.