Dan Marino(1983)
Eric Dickerson(1983)
Lawrence Taylor(1981)

Gotta go with QBs who were able to steer their teams to the playoffs, because that is a hard task for rookie QBs with all the pressure on them.

Dan Marino (1983)
Ben Roethlisberger (2004)
Kyle Orton (2005)

Randy Moss
Tomlinson, LaDainian
Eric Dickerson

If you're looking for individual performances, I'd have to say

Eric Dickerson - 2212 yds from scrimmage, 20 TDs
Peyton Manning - 3739 yds, 26 TD
Gale Sayers - 1374 yds from scrimmage, 22 TDs