1) Tom Brady
2) Steve Largeant
3) Doug Flutie
4) Adam Vinateri
5) Walter Payton

Mike Singletary! Without him, the 85 Bears would have been just another good team.

Payton? "Sweetness"??? Most overrated, perhaps. Nowhere near most underrated.

Honestly, the most underrated players are people you've never heard of. All defensive linemen or linebackers. No spotlight, no glory, jost outstanding football play.

Alan Faneca comes to mind.

Alan who?

Exactly. :-)

1. Gale Sayers
2. Tom Brady
3. Cris Carter, just as good a WR as Rice was
4. Eric Dickerson
5. Brad Johnson

1. John Elway
2. Marcus Allen
3. Jim Kelly
4. Sweetness
5.*Bo Jackson (the all time best)