MY vote goes for Antwaan Randle El. He is an extremely nice guy and is a terrific football player.
If you didnt know about him in college here is basically a recap of his career-Came in as a freshman Quarterback at Indiana and beat out Senior Jay Wright. From the first time you saw the guy play you knew he would be a star he had a cannon of an arm as fast as a runningback. Randle El isnt super fast, not Mike Vick speed, but he has agility like no other, and is extremely hard to catch. Through out his career he never played in a bowl game thanks to just about the worst Defense and other Offensive players. He made it fun to go to every home game every week even though we sucked because you knew he would give it his all and he had the chance to score on every play. I'm very happy to see that he is blossiming into a very good (not great) reciever. He will never be a star reciever but he is still a extremely good 2 reciever.

So who is the greatest player you ever saw live

GO IU

Reggie is very good, it would have been awesome to see him live

Check out these videos

http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=...
http://youtube.com/watch?v=-BWtwTkGUUI

Reggie Bush.

Randell El has a good future ahead of him.

Bo Jackson, without question

Thank-you nephew. But you didn't have to do this!
signed: Antwaan Randle El

The most exciting college football I ever saw was probably Michael Vick, Reggie Bush, or Vince Young. I'm only 14 so I never saw Bo Jackson play, but I would say him. Vick was just amazing on the run but couldn't throw worth a flip. Vince Young was unbelievable in the championship game and had about a seventy yard game winning touchdown run against OK State. However, I'm going with Reggie Bush because when he got the ball - whether it was running, catching, or kick returning - you felt he was going to score.

LT, if you look at some of his highlights he looks like hes playing with 10 yr olds even when he was on a team that wasnt a BCS contender, Bush at least had a solid line, LT had nothing

vince young, a little better than desmond howard, bo jackson, hershall walker barry sanders and a few others

I'd say that the best college football player I ever saw play in person was Larry Fitzgerald of Pitt (now with ARZ Cardinals), which is tough for me to admit seeing that I'm a WV Mountaineer and hate Pitt.

As far as the most exciting player...Steve Slaton, who plays for West Virginia right now. The guy can bust a 50 or 60 yard run on any play. You can't look away for a minute cause you're likely to miss a TD. I was at the WVU-Pitt game last week and the Mountaineers had a 4 play, 98-yard drive in something like 42 seconds. Slaton and Pat White are electric!

(Michael Vick was pretty amazing too!)