Be objective. The score is 21 to 21 2 minutes to play. The ball is at midfield. Which quarter back would you prefer was playing for your team?

Brady. He is good in the big game. I've seen Peyton psyche himself out trying to deceive the defense and call the perfect play while at the line.
I also think that Manning (although a top tier QB) can attribute much of his success to Marvin Harrison. Compare that to the way Brady spreads the ball around to all his receiving options.

My top three believe it or not:

1. Brady
2. Roethlisberger
3. Manning

Number one and number two own Super Bowl rings (yeah I know Big Ben didn't have a great game in the Super Bowl but he promised Bettis that he'll get him there). Report It

Tom Brady!

Brady...he's a proven winner

manning

what? girls like football too ya know!

MANNING..BRADY IS OVERRATED!!

brady. the only thing he is good at is winning.

Brady, and it's not a contest. Brady is the most clutch QB of the century. Peyton just choked away his chance for a superbowl to a wild-card team, at home.

Even though i hate the guy...

Brady he is way more accurate and persicion counts...u need the sideline passes to stop the clock....now if u where at the 99 maybe manning cuz he could bomb it downfield and let someone catch it...he seems to be able to always complete those crazy passes

Brady, he's been there.

Brady due to the fact that he has had a lot more experience in the pros leading the Patriots to superbowls and having to deal with those situations. Yes, Eli is a good quarterback but in that case the only thing that can help you is the experience that Tom Brady has.

Manning

Neither, because they both play like dog crap!!

I hate Brady. gotta go with Manning

Brady. Although I like Manning. Brady has demonstrated he can win. Manning is like Marino until he has proven himself otherwise.

manning all day!! he runs the best no huddle offense in football, maybe ever. most accurate and strongest throwing arm. brady is overrated.

shaggy:
i think he meant payton

brady is a baby u gotta go wit manning

Brady everytime 3 Super Bowl rings don't lie

Tough choise but history and the numbers don't lie. BRADY but I like manning better.

I hate the Pats but it took Brady three years to finally lose a play-off game! He might not be the best QB in the NFL during the season, but when a play-off game is on the line he most definitly is. Go Bills!

ToM bRaDy. DUH :p

Tom Brady! You've seen Peyton Manning in the playoffs. He chokes under pressure too much. Tom Brady can come up with the big plays even under pressure. In the Colts-Steelers game (2nd round of playoffs), Peyton Manning had a chance to win the game when the Bus fumbled the ball, but he only went 1-3 on that drive so they had to settle for a long field goal (which they missed). If Tom Brady were in that position, he would've gone down within the 10-yard line, maybe even a touchdown. But I think Tom Brady can perform a lot better under pressure than Peyton Manning can.

I like Manning. He is very good in two minute drills.

Manning