• Home
  • League
  • Team
  • Equipment
  • Knowledge
  • Related
  • Store
Home Page >> Football Related >> Football Hall of Fame
Who should/should not be in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?

Who do you think should be in the Pro Football Hall of Fame that isn't?

Who do you think should not be in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, but is?

Art Monk should have made the Hall of Fame already, and there is a good chance he'll never make the Hall. It's really a travesty considering his career.

I wouldn't take the Hall away from anyone, but there are certainly a few less deserving than Monk who have made it.

Is Kenny Anderson (Cincy QB) in? He should be. Maybe Phil Simms, too.

Art Monk should be and someday probally will be. I think all that got voted in deserve to be in.

Kevin Greene should be in, he has the 3rd highest sack total in history.

Micheal Irvin shouldn't in because he's a coke head and a Cowgirl.

Art Monk should clearly be in!

Put Art Monk in the Hall. (at retirement held record for most consecutive games with a catch only Jerry Rice passed it)
Take Michael Irvin (the pushoff king, gold suit wearing coke head), out.

Art Monk, Jack Reynolds, Ken Anderson, or Henry Ellard would all be great choices. It is unbelievable that Irvin was inducted - - was he a first ballot selection? I'm not saying condemn the man for life for his previous drug problem and otherwise reckless behaviors - - but they could have waited some years and inducted others who are more deserving (and there are many).

Derrick Thomas 7 sacks in one game, Kick Michael Irvin out

I'm not sure about who's in but shouldn't be. But Richard Dent isn't ,but sure should be!

Randall Cunningham should be in, because he paved the way and totally revolutionized the QB position. He also has more touchdowns and less interceptions than Troy Aikman.

Should be in, but aren't (mixes current eligibles not in yet and seniors candidate worthies):

END (pre 1950): Lavie Dilweg

BACK (pre 1950): Verne Lewellen

LINEMEN (pre 1950): Duke Slater, Al Wistert, Riley Matheson

CENTER: Mick Tingelhoff, Dermontti Dawson

GUARD: Steve Wisniewski, Randall McDaniel, Russ Grimm, Ed Budde, Walt Sweeney, Dick Stanfel, Jerry Kramer

OFFENSIVE TACKLE: Gary Zimmerman, Jim Tyrer

WIDE RECEIVERS: Henry Ellard, Art Monk, Billy Wilson, Bill Howton, Cliff Branch, Drew Pearson, Harold Carmichael, Andre Reed, Irving Fryar, Bob Hayes, Otis Taylor

TIGHT ENDS: Jerry Smith, Pete Retzlaff, Ben Coates

QUARTERBACKS: Ken Anderson

RUNNING BACKS: Floyd Little

DEFENSIVE LINEMEN: Gene Brito, Claude Humphrey, Chris Doleman, L.C. Greenwood, Cortez Kennedy

LINEBACKERS: Robert Brazile, Chuck Howley, Maxie Baughan, Chris Hanburger, Les Richter, Randy Gradishar, Tommy Nobis, Derrick Thomas, Joe Fortunato

DEFENSIVE BACKS: Abe Woodson, Cliff Harris, Jim Patton, Bobby Dillon, Jack Butler, Johnny Robinson, Lemar Parrish, Kenny Easley, Joey Browner, Steve Atwater, Leroy Butler, Lester Hayes

KICKERS/PUNTERS: Tommy Davis, Nick Lowery, Ray Guy

Some positions tend to be under-represented in the PFHoF, especially WR, DB, G, K/P, and LB (especially corner LB).

Can't think of any players who are in that shouldn't be there. And sorry, but unlike the Baseball Hall of Fame, PFHoF guidelines explicitly prohibit using character issues to exclude players. One might not like O.J. Simpson, Michael Irvin, or Lawrence Taylor for one reason or another, but that's not an issue here.

Topic Related
  • Would Tiki Barber have made the Hall of Fame if he played another 3 or 4 seasons?
  • Will Tiki Barber get into the Hall of Fame?
  • Which member of the Pro Football Hall Of Fame...?
  • Would Terry Bradshaw be in the Hall of Fame if he had played for the Bengals?
  • Who else here wants Art Monk in the Hall of Fame?
  • Who should/should not be in the Pro Football Hall of Fame?
  • About Us|Conditions of Use|Privacy Notice|Add Favorite|Contact Webmaster

    ©2000-2007 nokiasugarbowl.com All rights reserved.