I dont know which one to get. Ive never gotten a NCAA football game but ive gotten Madden every year since 2001. Madden games always look the same every year and play the same every year except with an updated roster. I think i might want to switch over to NCAA football this year. Should I get NCAA football 08 or just stick with MAdden 08?

I say a Milkshake will have more action.

it bringz allllll the boyz to the " yard ".


{No homo No homo}

i got ncaa 08 on the ps3 and its cool. im gonna get madden 08 when it comes out too. i suggest u get both

NCAA game rules. I haven't played 08 yet, but 07 is great, and the various "in game" games are cool too. In Dynasty mode the recruiting through the season can be a challenge. Game play is simmilar to Madden, but I think NCAA is more fun

madden this year the ncaa game really slowed up and running is soooo slow and unrealistic. Either get madden 08 or Ncaa 07.

I'm facing the same dilemma. I don't know if I should get it, being that Madden comes out in a couple of weeks. I've downloaded the demo for xbox 360, and its alright. No cheerleaders, no medical staff when players get hurt, no dirtstains on uniforms, and this is supposed to be next-gen? 2K does a better job at next gen, their basketball games feature sweat and other real-life scenarios. EA needs to step it up, the best football game i ever bought was 2K5, it was $20 and way better than any EA football game i played. The presentation, dirt on uniforms, halftime shows, they even showed highlights from other games, and they had Chris Berman to boot.

easy answer get both

madden is better by far if u have xbox 360 u can download the ncaa 08 demo for free and see what im talkin about. i plyd the demo and it was fun but ive played madden for a long time and still like it better. and carolina boy i agree with u 100% nfl 2k5 was the bets game i ever bought but i still like madden alot to

?????????? Madden always beets anything else, ALWAYS

I haven't played NCAA 2008 but I have NCAA 2007 and Madden 2007 If u get both 08 versions u can create a player in college and then export him to madden after playing for 3-4 seasons in NCAA it is pretty cool at lest in the 2007 games.

Personally I like the college game better trying to rebuild through recruiting is a fun challenge. The only bad thing in NCAA 2007 is the create a team mode is not very deep but other than than the NCAA games are great

Get NCAA football 08. Madden games get boring after a while but not ncaa.

Get NCAA 08 this year then get Madden 09 next year then get NCAA 10 the year after that and so on, or get both games every year

They are pretty much the exact same game. Sure there are a few little differences, but all in all it's the same. I only buy NCAA to take a favorite player from college to the pros.

Ncaa was good last year so it is going to suck this year its been like that since The ncaa with Ricky williams on the cover. I would go with madden, its always a safer bet.

Madden. I played a demo for ncca and it sucked.

if i could only get 1 it would be madden but get ncaa also if you can because i have it and it is great plus importing your draft class in madden is also fun